🇪🇺Contracts · leasing

Lease and charter contracts for a business jet: the clauses that decide control, VAT and liability

A business jet rarely sits under one contract: a lease, a management agreement, charter terms, a loan and an insurance policy, each drafted by a different adviser. When they disagree about who operates the aircraft and who pays for what, the inspector, the insurer and the tax auditor will each pick the version that suits them.

The short version
  • The contract type decides the operator: the lessee in a dry lease, the lessor in a wet lease, the AOC holder in a charter.
  • The operator clause, the insurance, the CAMO contract and the ETS account must all name the same party.
  • Rent is a hire of a means of transport for VAT: duration, place of handover and the invoicing entity decide where it is taxed.
  • Leases to an AOC holder need prior approval, and a financier needs IDERA, return conditions and a quiet enjoyment deal that works.

Owners read aircraft contracts for price and term. The trouble is elsewhere: a vague sentence on operational control, a lease that slips over thirty days, an invoice from the wrong company, an insurance certificate that omits the bank. Each later becomes the deciding fact in an investigation, an audit or an enforcement.

This article goes through the contract clause by clause, with the rule each clause must satisfy. Our articles on leasing structures and management agreements cover the structural choices; here the focus is the wording.

Four contracts, four operators

EU air operations law defines the two lease types by whose responsibility the aircraft flies under. In a dry lease the aircraft is operated under the AOC, or for non-CAT commercial operations the responsibility, of the lessee; in a wet lease it is operated, with crew, under the AOC or responsibility of the lessor. Both definitions describe agreements between undertakings or operators: a lease is a contract between parties who carry operational responsibility.

A charter agreement is different in kind: the customer buys a flight, and the AOC holder carries the passengers under its own certificate. A management agreement is a services contract; the manager may or may not be the operator. Label each contract correctly first.

ContractOperatorCustomer getsVAT character
Dry leaseThe lesseeThe aircraft, without crewHire of a means of transport
Wet leaseThe lessorAircraft and crewHire or transport, depending on what is supplied
Charter agreementThe AOC holderA flight or series of flightsPassenger transport
Management agreementOwner or manager, as the declaration saysServices to run the aircraftSupply of services

Parties and operational control

The parties clause should name legal entities, not brands: the registered owner, the lessee or operator, the manager and any financier taking an assignment. Registered owner, title holder and lessor should be the same company, or the chain between them documented.

The operator clause is the most important sentence in the document. It should name the operator, its certificate or declaration, and the flights covered, and state that this party holds operational control: authority over initiating, continuing, diverting and terminating each flight, crew rostering and dispatch. An owner right to “direct” flights or approve crew in a dry lease to an AOC holder undermines the lease. Owners keep commercial rights (when, where, with whom); operators keep the operational decisions.

Test the operator clause

Read it alongside the AOC or declaration, the insurance certificate, the CAMO contract and the ETS registration. If any of them names a different operator, the clause is not doing its job.

Term and use rights

Commencement should be tied to a signed delivery receipt recording date, place, hours and cycles: later evidence for VAT, customs and return condition.

Use rights are where owner and operator collide. The clause should set owner priority and notice, and say under whose operation owner flights take place. If the aircraft stays on the AOC while the owner’s own operating entity flies it privately, the rules allow this only for a continuous period not exceeding 30 days, under an approved procedure identifying who holds operational control of each flight and how the aircraft is handed back, with continuing airworthiness staying with the AOC holder’s CAMO. “Unrestricted private use” without that procedure is a promise the operator cannot lawfully keep.

The simpler alternative is for the owner to fly as a charter customer at agreed rates. That changes the VAT and ETS position, so the contract should state the model.

Rent, VAT and the invoice

A dry lease is a hire of a means of transport. Short-term hire (continuous possession for no more than thirty days) is taxed where the aircraft is put at the customer’s disposal. Longer hire to a private customer is taxed where the customer resides; to a business, usually where the lessee is established, by reverse charge. Duration is read from the contract, but only as a presumption, and consecutive contracts between the same parties for the same aircraft are added together. A chain of 29-day leases is a long-term hire.

A charter is passenger transport, taxed where the transport takes place, with international legs exempt or zero-rated in many Member States. A wet lease turns on whether the customer receives an aircraft at its disposal or a transport service, so describe what is actually supplied.

The rent clause should state the amount net of VAT, the expected place of supply, the invoicing entity (the contracting lessor, under its own VAT number), the paying entity (the contracting lessee) and a gross-up. Rent invoiced by a manager or paid by a non-party is a gift to an auditor.

The lease says who operates. The invoice says who supplied what to whom. When the two tell different stories, the tax authority believes the invoice.

BCA Aviation, on lease and charter contracts

Maintenance and CAMO

Continuing airworthiness starts with the owner, and that responsibility transfers to the lessee only if the lessee is named on the registration document or the lease says so. For aircraft used by an air carrier, the operator is responsible and holds the CAMO approval as part of its certificate. A dry lease should therefore say expressly that the lessee assumes continuing airworthiness, which CAMO performs it, and under which maintenance programme.

The maintenance clause then allocates cost and reserves, gives the owner inspection rights, requires complete, traceable records and makes modifications subject to the lessor’s consent.

Insurance

The operator insures, because the operator carries the risk. The clause should require hull all risks and hull war cover for an agreed value at least equal to the lessor’s or financier’s exposure, and liability cover at a stated limit, never below the minimums of Regulation (EC) No 785/2004.

Lessor, owner and financier should be additional insureds on liability, with the financier as loss payee on hull and subrogation waived against all of them. What a lender cares about most is breach of warranty protection: its cover continues even if the operator breaches a policy condition, for example by flying outside the permitted territory. The London market uses a standard contract endorsement, AVN 67B being the familiar one. Add notice before cancellation and run-off liability cover after the lease ends.

Return conditions

Return conditions decide what the aircraft is worth when the lease ends. The clause should fix the return location (relevant for customs if the aircraft leaves the Union), a valid certificate of airworthiness and airworthiness review certificate, a minimum maintenance condition or compensation for any shortfall, and engine condition supported by inspection data. Records are half the asset: require full records and CAMO file handover, a return inspection, and rent until a non-compliant aircraft is put right.

Default, repossession and quiet enjoyment

Events of default typically cover non-payment, insurance lapse, loss of the AOC, insolvency and sanctions. For a mobile asset, repossession is only as good as the ability to take the aircraft off the register and out of the country. Where the debtor has agreed, the creditor can procure de-registration and export. In States that have made the relevant declaration, the registered owner or operator signs an irrevocable de-registration and export request authorisation (IDERA) in the creditor’s favour, lodged with the register. The lease should oblige the lessee to sign it, register the international interest and cooperate with enforcement; our article on financing a business jet covers the registry side.

Quiet enjoyment is the lessee’s counterweight: while no default continues, neither the lessor nor anyone claiming through it will disturb the lessee’s possession. Where the aircraft is financed, the lessee needs the same promise from the bank in a quiet enjoyment letter, or the owner’s loan default can ground an operator that has paid every instalment.

Governing law and jurisdiction

Parties may choose the law of their contract, and EU courts will apply it even without any connection to the deal. The choice governs the contract, not title, mortgages or registration, and it does not displace mandatory aviation and tax rules. Without a choice, default rules apply that rarely give the answer both sides would have picked.

Jurisdiction needs its own clause. A clause choosing the courts of a Member State works regardless of domicile and is exclusive unless agreed otherwise, so an asymmetric lender clause must say so expressly. Since Brexit, a clause choosing the English courts relies in EU courts on the 2005 Hague Choice of Court Convention or national law.

Regulatory approvals

Any lease of an aircraft used by an EU AOC holder needs prior approval by the competent authority. Dry lease-in of a third-country-registered aircraft is approved only for an operational need an EU-registered aircraft cannot meet, and for no more than seven months in any twelve; dry lease-out needs approval with the lease terms; wet lease-out needs notification. The lease should make approval a condition precedent to delivery.

Where the register and the operator sit in different States, the State of registry can transfer oversight functions to the operator’s State. The contract should say whether an Article 83 bis agreement is needed and who requests it. Our EU operations and AOC service handles these filings.

The ETS clause

Under the EU ETS, the aircraft operator is the person operating the aircraft when the flight is performed; only where that person is not known or not identified by the owner does the obligation fall on the owner. The ETS obligation therefore follows the operator clause.

The clause should name the ETS account holder, require fuel data to be shared, pass allowance costs through per flight, deal with surrender for a year that straddles termination, and indemnify the owner against penalties.

The clause checklist

ClauseWhat it must sayRed flag
PartiesOwner, lessor, lessee, manager, financier as legal entitiesA family office signing for the “group”
OperatorNamed operator, certificate or declaration, flights coveredOwner rights to direct flights in a dry lease
Term and useDelivery receipt; owner priority; whose operation owner flights run under“Unrestricted private use” of an AOC aircraft
Rent and VATNet rent, place of supply, invoicing and paying entity, gross-upInvoices from a non-party; chained 29-day leases
CAMO and maintenanceWho assumes continuing airworthiness; cost, reserves, recordsSilence, leaving responsibility with the owner
InsuranceHull, war, liability; additional insureds; loss payee; breach of warrantyCertificate naming only the operator
ReturnLocation, condition, records, inspection, compensation“Fair wear and tear excepted” and nothing more
DefaultEvents of default, repossession, IDERA, international interestNo IDERA where the register records them
Quiet enjoymentLessor covenant plus a letter from its financierCovenant from the lessor only
Law and forumExpress choice of law; courts or arbitrationNo choice, or a forum with no reach
ApprovalsLease approval as condition precedent; Article 83 bisCommercial flights before approval
ETSAccount holder, data, cost pass-through, penaltiesNo ETS clause at all

A worked example

Take a family company that buys a large-cabin jet with bank finance, registers it in a Member State whose register records IDERAs, and dry leases it to an AOC holder in another Member State for charter. The family wants about forty days a year.

The dry lease names the AOC holder as operator and moves continuing airworthiness to its CAMO. The lease is long-term and between businesses, so the owning company invoices rent in its own name, with reverse charge where the AOC holder is established. Lease approval is a condition precedent, and an Article 83 bis agreement is requested. The family flies as a charter customer, so there is no second operator. The AOC holder is the ETS operator and prices allowances into each charter. The bank is loss payee with breach of warranty protection, holds an IDERA, and gives the operator a quiet enjoyment letter. Every document names the same operator.

Mistakes we see

The first is the hybrid lease: a “dry lease” that lets the owner choose crew and approve flights, so no one can say who held operational control. The second is the slipping term: short leases renewed back to back, which become one long-term hire. The third is the wrong invoice: rent billed or paid by a company that is not a party.

The fourth is the insurance gap: no cover for the owning company or the bank. The fifth is flying before approval. The sixth is no ETS clause, so the owner learns it is the default aircraft operator from a compliance notice. All six are cheaper to fix before signing.

Key terms

Dry lease Reg. 965/2012Aircraft operated under the lessee’s AOC or responsibility.
Wet lease Reg. 965/2012Aircraft operated, with crew, under the lessor’s AOC or responsibility.
Operational control operationsAuthority over initiating, continuing, diverting and terminating a flight.
Breach of warranty insuranceKeeps the lessor’s and financier’s cover in force if the operator breaches the policy.
IDERA Cape Town ProtocolIrrevocable authorisation letting the creditor de-register and export the aircraft.
Quiet enjoyment leasingPromise not to disturb the lessee’s possession while no default continues.
Review your contracts

Do your lease, charter and management contracts name the same operator?

We review the contract set clause by clause and align it with the AOC, the CAMO, the insurance, the VAT position and the financing.

WhatsApp

Frequently asked

Is a management agreement a lease?

Not by itself. If the aircraft is also placed on the manager’s AOC, there is usually a lease as well, and that lease needs approval.

Can I fly my own aircraft privately while it is on a charter AOC?

Yes: through your own operating entity for up to 30 continuous days under an approved procedure, or as a charter customer. The contract should say which.

Why does the length of a lease matter for VAT?

Hire of up to thirty days is taxed where the aircraft is handed over; longer hire where the customer is established or resides. Consecutive contracts are added together.

Why does my bank insist on breach of warranty cover?

It keeps the bank insured even if the operator breaches a policy condition, so an operator’s mistake cannot leave the bank uncovered for a total loss.

Who pays for EU ETS allowances on a leased jet?

The operator named in the lease carries the legal obligation; the contract decides who bears the cost.

Sources & references
  1. Regulation (EU) No 965/2012: Annex I, ORO.AOC.110, ORO.GEN.310; Regulation (EU) No 1321/2014, M.A.201.
  2. Directive 2006/112/EC, Article 56; Implementing Regulation (EU) No 282/2011, Articles 38–40.
  3. Rome I, Brussels I bis, 2005 Hague Choice of Court Convention.
  4. Cape Town Aircraft Protocol and IDERA form; Chicago Convention, Article 83 bis; Directive 2003/87/EC; Regulation (EC) No 785/2004.
AB
Author

Alexander Baranov

Founder, BCA Group · aircraft VAT & structuring

Alexander advises owners, family offices, operators and financiers on aircraft lease, charter and management contracts across the EU, from a Germany-based practice.

How we work: we read the lease, the charter terms, the insurance and the loan as one contract set, so they all name the same operator.

Last reviewed 15 November 2026.

One aircraft, one operator, every contract agreeing.

Send us your lease, charter or management contracts. We will mark the clauses that decide control, VAT and liability, and tell you what to change.

More insights